听说关注了IPENGLISH的同学都考到了高分哦
作者:黄威
澳大利亚雅培英语创始人兼主讲老师。前武汉新东方主讲,雅思全科8分/PTE满分获得者。授课学员累计逾万人,带出高分/满分学员无数。在澳生活10年,教学之余研究语言文化和英语实际应用场景。
在PTE的Summarize Written Text中有这样一道题:
大概意思就是讲,在澳洲是世界上唯一的一个需要强制投票的民主社会,而不投票是会收到罚单的。
A democratic country should have the right to decide whether to vote or not. It is strange that after decades of crawling up the political backside of the US, Australians don’t have that right. Being fined for not voting reminds me of the old saying “you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make him drink”. The fine is not for failing to vote but for failing to have your name marked off a list!
Forcing people to make a decision just means they’ll make the easiest, quickest decision they can, not the best one. You need an informed electorate for compulsory voting to work. However, the reality is that nobody knows anything about the candidates and promotional material is not readily available. I’d rather 80% of people didn’t vote than have them all just pick the first recognisable name on the ballot sheet. Then at least the government is elected by the 20% who care and make informed decisions. Otherwise it is largely pot chance who gets elected. Furthermore, compulsory voting doesn’t ensure that the entire electorate is engaged in the democratic process. Those who don’t want to vote can simply turn up and get their name marked off, without even putting pencil to paper. But you’re seriously deluding yourself if you think that this is what all those who don’t care about government do when they turn up to the polling booth. Voluntary voting at least ensures those who vote are the ones that care enough to do so. Perhaps somebody could enlighten me as to the reason why, to the best of my knowledge, Australia is the only ‘democracy’ that has compulsory voting. It is certainly not compulsory in the USA, England, Canada, New Zealand, Philippines or any other European or Asian democracy that I am aware of. Compulsory voting is, however, mandatory in most communist regimes.
那么,我们一起来看一下这篇文章的背景知识吧:
依照澳大利亚联邦法律,在没有充分理由的前提下,没有投票会收到20刀的罚款。虽然不多,但是也算是一个霸王条款了。
但是!强制投票的只适用于eligible Australian citizens, 而并非留学生/PR持有者,也就是就算拿到绿卡了,也不需要投票,除非转国籍了。
而澳洲强制投票是否违背民主的本质在不同的媒体上也受到了广泛的讨论:
BBC报道称,在澳大利亚的强制投票要求下,94%的选民有参与投票,而英国只有65%,美国更是只有可怜的57%投票率。
而卫报更是对澳大利亚的投票系统大加赞扬,称其成功的避免了‘Trumpism’川普主义。美国现总统川普在仅有1/4支持率的情况下依旧成功的当选了总统,这归功于美国总统大选的整体投票率底下,文章称‘在澳洲这样一个高投票率的国家,这样的事情是绝对不会发生的’。
那么,让我们再次回到我们的题目中。在了解了上述背景知识以后,这篇文章选点就并不是那么困难了,全文有3个要点是必须概括的:
1. Australia is the only democracy country that has compulsory voting 文章主旨:澳大利亚是民主社会中唯一一个需要强制投票的国家。
2. Forcing people to make a decision just means they'll make the easiest, quickest decision they can, not the best one. 主旨所造成的影响1 - 这会让选民乱投
3. compulsory voting doesn't ensure that the entire electorate is engaged in the democratic process. 主旨所造成的影响2 - 这会让竞选过程变得不民主。
参考答案:
Australia is the only democracy country that has compulsory voting, which leads to voters making the easiest, quickest decision instead of the best one, and such compulsory voting doesn't ensure that the entire electorate is engaged in the democratic process.
那么,同学们认为澳大利亚的强制投票是否应该呢?
文章原创:黄威
排版/整编:猫叔徐超 & Cindy
更多精彩英语学习
关注雅培英语公众号IPENGLISH
有奖竞答 | 哈利波特名场面英文解析,你知道为什么全书使用过去式吗?答对送电影票